Year 5’s Spirited Sparta and Athens Debate

          

Today in History, Year 5 took part in a lively debate to decide whether it would have been better to live in Athens or Sparta. The children explored a range of sources to learn about life in each city, carefully choosing evidence to support their ideas and considering how the context of the time might have shaped people’s experiences. Before the debate, they completed a Diamond 9 activity to rank which points were the most important to their arguments, helping them focus on the strongest evidence and ideas.

During the debate, they compared the societies, looking at the roles, beliefs, and daily lives of men, women, and children, and examining the cultural, social, and political differences that made Athens and Sparta unique. The class also explored the origins of democracy in Athens and reflected on how these ancient civilisations have influenced the world we live in today.

"I think that a good reason to live in Sparta is you were given military protection, which kept you and your family safe from any possible invaders." Vinnie

"As a child in Sparta, you would be much fitter and healthier becuase they trained from such a young age." Harry

"Athenians were obviously the best warriors because they were named after Athena, the goddess of warfare!" Mia

The activity encouraged the children to analyse evidence, form well-reasoned arguments, and think critically about continuity and change in history. It was a fantastic way for Year 5 to engage with the past, and their enthusiasm and thoughtful contributions made the debate both informative and fun! Excellent work, Year 5!